More News

Ex-SBHS superintendent Perales sentenced in gun incident

Perales was sentenced for an incident which occurred in October 2016. He resigned from his position as San Benito High School Superintendent in January 2017.


Former San Benito High School Superintendent John Perales has been sentenced to 20 days in county jail, probation and community service after pleading no contest to using a handgun to threaten a young man outside his Gilroy home in 2016.

The jail time was suspended, however, as long as Perales abides by the terms of his probation, according to Santa Clara County Deputy District Attorney Daniel Borca, who prosecuted the case.

Borca had recommended 60 days in jail, out of a maximum allowable term of one year, and told BenitoLink that jail time was “appropriate” because the incident could have ended tragically.

Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Edward F. Lee disagreed with the District Attorney’s recommendation; he stayed his own 20-day jail term and ordered Perales to serve two years of court-supervised probation and perform 120 hours of community service in connection with the Oct. 22, 2016 incident outside Perales’ Greystone Court home in Gilroy.

In addition, Lee at the Sept. 29 sentencing hearing in Santa Clara County Superior Court in Morgan Hill ordered Perales to submit at any time to searches by law enforcement officials and to refrain from owning or possessing a firearm for 10 years, and to stay at least 300 yards from his victim, Reynaldo Lara, of Gilroy, a former Gilroy High School student.

Borca formally objected in court to Lee’s sentence, and later told BenitoLink in an email, “Mr. Lara was present in court and provided heartfelt remarks about the impact this incident had on him.”

Borca continued: “This incident could have ended tragically, but Mr. Lara has demonstrated considerable resolve in putting this past him. Despite the people’s disagreement with the sentence, we believe the community is going to be protected because the defendant can no longer possess a firearm.”

In the meantime, four days after he was sentenced, Perales posted a note on his Facebook page at, saying he might be a candidate for the Gilroy Unified School District Board of Trustees.

It reads: “Dear friends, I have given much thought to the idea of seeking a seat on the Gilroy Unified School District’s Board of Education. I have gone back and forth and just when I seem to resign myself to not run, I am encouraged by dear friends, community members and parents of students. I bring a fresh lens to the School Board/District and come with much experience in K-12 Education. Still, I will continue to pray about this path and seek God's will. I humbly ask for your support.”

In seeking a warrant for Perales’ arrest last year on the misdemeanor charge of exhibiting a firearm and threatening someone, the district attorney alleged that the former school superintendent did “…draw and exhibit a firearm, a(n) H&K .45-caliber semi-automatic handgun, in a rude, angry and threatening manner and did unlawfully use the same in a fight and quarrel,” a violation of California Penal Code Section 417, subsection (a)(2).

For his part, Perales on Friday said: “In hindsight…I wish it had never happened.”

He was steadfast, however, in his belief that he acted out of legitimate safety concerns.

He said that prior to the incident there had been a rash of burglaries in the neighborhood and that he had been a victim.

“We live in a free world and we are free to protect our homes, and I stand by that I was protecting my home. Unfortunately, that is not the way the DA saw it or the court system saw it,” he said.

Perales added: “I am looking forward to putting a very difficult time in my life past me and moving forward and focusing on the positive aspects I have gained through the experience…I am looking forward to just trying to move past this dark time in my life.”

And while Perales’ tenure at the helm of the SBHS district was not always smooth, he said of those he worked with and for, “I miss them dearly, they are a wonderful community.”

He praised SBHS for recent test score successes and said, “I had nothing but fond experiences there and I just wish them the best.”

As the Gilroy incident that lead to his legal troubles began, Lara was seated in his car, which was parked at the curb outside the Perales home, reportedly waiting for a friend who lived next door.

When Perales saw the young man, he approached him, brandished his handgun and confronted Lara, according to authorities.

A complaint was lodged with the Gilroy Police who investigated and referred the case to the district attorney.

Between entering his no contest plea in August and the sentencing, Perales was hired as Director of Media Education and Partnerships by Gilroy-based CMAP, a nonprofit media operation that trains youth and others in media production and has done some work with BenitoLink.

Borca confirmed that concerns over Perales’ behavior around youth were “reasonable questions.”

He told BenitoLink that he was satisfied the case will be “reported to the Department of Justice and they’ll do what is appropriate.” He said that would include matters involving employers and credentials. 


Perales said Friday that CMAP works with “children” and that Mr. Lara was an adult, and so he sees no issue in him, Perales, working at CMAP since he has spent a career in education.

CMAP executive director Becca King Reed, Perales’ new boss, did not return a call from BenitoLink.

Headquartered at Christopher High School during part of Perales’ tenure as its principal, CMAP now shares space with Greenhouse Coworking in a building in the heart of downtown Gilroy.

Perales served as the SBHS top administrator from around March 2014 until early January 2017.

For 2014 and 2015, he was paid a combined total of $308,250 in salary and other pay, plus about $57,000 in benefits, according to the website, Figures for 2016 were not immediately available.

Perales left SBHS abruptly after meeting with the school board in the wake of being charged in December 2016 with one misdemeanor count of violating section 417 (a)(2) of the California Penal Code in connection with the Gilroy incident.

Crimes defined in Section 417 are commonly referred to as brandishing a firearm. Under certain circumstances it can be charged as a felony, for example when committed in the presence of a police officer or at a daycare center, according to Borca.

Perales’ behavior did not meet the statutory requirements of a felony charge, according to the district attorney’s office, which also confirmed that Perales was in legal possession of the gun at the time of the incident.

Perales’ home is a short walk from Gilroy Unified School District’s Rod Kelley Elementary School.

In California, it’s against the law to have or use a firearm illegally within 1,000 feet of a school.

It’s unclear if the incident was within that distance. Gilroy police did not allege a violation of California’s so-called safe-school zone laws, according to the district attorney’s office. Therefore it was not considered when charges were filed and could not now be charged.

Before his stint at SBHS, Perales was the founding principal of Gilroy’s $58 million Christopher High School. He also was a human resources official for the Gilroy Unified School District.



BenitoLink Logo

Become a Member Today

Support your local independent news.

We work hard to give you the news and information you need. By becoming a member, you will be part of something bigger; BenitoLink, your community-supported news source.


jackmfoley's picture
Jack Foley (jackmfoley)

Jack Foley is a veteran journalist on the BenitoLink team. Foley is a Pulitzer co-winner for the San Jose Mercury News staff’s coverage of the Loma Prieta Earthquake. He was also nominated for a Pulitzer by the Center for Public Interest Law for a highly-lauded series that exposed California’s lax policing of bad doctors. He is an experienced investigative reporter who worked for the San Jose Mercury News for more than 20 years. Foley covered San Benito County news on and off throughout his professional career. In addition to his more than three decades in journalism as a reporter, photojournalist and editor, Foley also has taught news writing at Gavilan College, worked in the nonprofit, affordable housing field, including in San Benito County, and has done high level public affairs work for NASA.


“We live in a free world and we are free to protect our homes, and I stand by that I was protecting my home. Unfortunately, that is not the way the DA saw it or the court system saw it,” he (Perales) said. That statement is not an expression of remorse, nor does Perales show that he accepts the consequences of his illegal, violent and menacing behavior towards an innocent person minding his own business. 

I submit we live in a free world and we are free to sit in parked cars on a public street without malicious gun-wielding harassment and unnecessary provocation. Fortunately, the DA and the judge took appropriate actions to sentence Perales accordingly. 

It is extremely disturbing that anyone who poses a perceived threat to Perales is subject to the following: “…draw and exhibit a firearm, a(n) H&K .45-caliber semi-automatic handgun, in a rude, angry and threatening manner and did unlawfully use the same in a fight and quarrel,” a violation of California Penal Code Section 417, subsection (a)(2).

Unfortunately, CMAP-TV, a nonprofit that exists and is subsidized through public cable TV franchise revenue, showed questionable judgment in hiring an employee who now has a conviction and criminal record for a gun charge based on irrational, psychopathic behavior toward an innocent member of the public. Let's hope Perales never feels threatened by other members of the public who utilize the TV station's services or reacts similarly during a spirited boardroom debate in the future.


I cannot believe that this was charged as a misdemeanor not a felony. Mr Perales was on a public street, not his private property, when he brandished the handgun. He obviously was not "defending his home" as he stated but was threatening the life of a stranger.

Few job applications ask if you have ever been convicted of a misdemeanor. Most look for felony convictions. I doubt if he can be fired for having a conviction that the company does not normally investigate. If Mr Perales does run for the trustee position, we will soon learn if the public really cares about his ability to guide children. If he is elected, that will say more about the voters' apathy than Mr Perales' qualifications.

BTW, did his wife take over ownership of the handgun? Probably still sitting on the coffee table for quick defense of the Perales' home.

--William McCarey

CMAP-TV receives public funding via San Benito County government as a beneficiary of Charter Spectrum's cable TV franchise. It has also received grant funding from the Community Foundation for San Benito County to subsidize its Youth Media program which Mr. Perales supervises.

From CMAP-TV's website: John Perales, Program Director

"John manages day-to-day operations at CMAP. He also works with the Communities we serve to build partnerships that support our mission and community education opportunities. Prior to joining CMAP, John worked extensively in the education sector."

San Benito County government should take a stand against gun violence and investigate the professional judgment of CMAP-TV and its hiring practices of convicted gun violence offenders who show no remorse for their actions, nor accept the consequences of the justice system that protects the public - and especially our youth - from such demonstrated psychopathic behavior. 

Here's another story from 2011 that sounds eerily familiar to Mr. Perales circumstances. A so-called 'regular guy' volunteered at a public access TV station in San Jose, was a truck driver, got into some trouble for violence and ended up murdering 3 people. 

Along with working at the cement plant, Allman also was a contributing producer at the San Jose public access TV channel CreaTV and an author who wrote a book, “Amazing Grace,” that addressed domestic violence issues.

Ironically, Allman had a misdemeanor conviction for disturbing the peace – plea bargained down from domestic violence – for an incident that occurred in San Mateo on Aug. 9, 1992, San Mateo County District Attorney Steve Wagstaffe said. Allman served two days in jail and underwent 48 hours of domestic violence training after that conviction.

The perpetrator was shot and killed by police in a neighborhood where I used to work. People who commit acts of gun violence are extremely dangerous. 

There are two primary definitions of the word judgment -

1) the ability to make considered decisions or come to sensible conclusions and  2)  a misfortune or calamity viewed as a divine punishment.

Mr. Perales didn't do number one; some would say he received number two for his error.

I wish him a better future.

Marty Richman

Add new comment

Add Facebook comment

Comment using your Facebook account. Facebook comments will be published on this page, and on Facebook. It will not be posted to the "Recent Comments" list on the BenitoLink front page.