More News

Public art mural defaced by vandalism in Hollister

San Benito Street mural was vandalized by a perpetrator who bragged about his work on the social media platform Instagram
The alleged tagger posted about the vandalism on Instagram.

A public art mural on San Benito Street has been "tagged" — or defaced with spray paint — in an act of vandalism that may be traced back to the perpetrator who bragged about his "work" on the social media platform Instagram. The mural is about a year old and the result of a collaboration of local artists with a donation from the Community Foundation for San Benito County, which paid for the art supplies, according to a BenitoLink article from Jan. 28.

Local artist Rolan Resendiz said he discovered that the alleged vandal "has an Instagram account dedicated to all his graffiti. Someone found him on Instagram and told us. He posted a pic of our mural he defaced and claimed he did it," said Resendiz.

"One of the artists (Adam Valentino) who worked on the mural found it. He specializes in aerosol (graffiti) work. I'm assuming he searched what the guy tags and his name was as a hash tag, because he hash tagged it on that picture," Resendiz said. "People (who saw what he had done via his Instagram account) were giving him crap after my post so his account is now private." According to the social media sleuthing, the alleged perpetrator is named "Miguel" and hails from Los Angeles.

As struggling artists themselves, Resendiz and his partner, Joel Esqueda​, said they preferred to utilize restorative justice and invite the perpetrator to help repair the damage he's done by defacing public art and help channel his talent in a beneficial way to the community.

"He's a young kid," Resendiz said. "He wants to be creative and I want to support that, but I'd like to if I can reach out to him and show him that he can be creative without breaking the legal law and code of ethics between artists. I feel like he needs a creative outlet, but his actions are a little misdirected. I wouldn't mind trying to talk some sense into this kid and collaborate with him. It looks like he's from L.A. He might be here visiting."

And of course, there is a tangible as well as an aesthetic value to the public art mural on San Benito Street. Resendiz estimates the dollar value of the mural, if it were commissioned by a benefactor, to be between $5,000 and $10,000. 

"It took us a month to do," he said. "Three main artists worked on it off and on. We generally charge about a $100 a day for a piece like that. The Community Foundation donated $500 in supplies. It's a big piece. If each artist was out there every day, which they were not, I'd give them each $100 a day plus materials. We didn't really track hours, the artists donated their time to complete the project," he said.

Since the mural was completed earlier this year, Resendiz and Esqueda started a local art business called "ARTI-Culture" at 910 Monterey St. in the old Hazel Hawkins Hospital building. The new office is under construction and is scheduled to open early in 2017. They have been contracted to create artistic works for First 5 San Benito and other businesses in the community. 

The defaced property is expected to be repaired in a week or so by the same artists who completed the work. If community members are aware who is responsible for the tagging, Resendiz said to let the person know there are other artists willing to help him express his artistic creativity in such a way so that he won't run afoul of the law. 


BenitoLink Logo

Become a Member Today

Support your local independent news.

We work hard to give you the news and information you need. By becoming a member, you will be part of something bigger; BenitoLink, your community-supported news source.


Michael Smith (Michael Smith)

Pro-economic growth, pro-music, pro-science, pro-retirement.


I have no tolerance for vandalism and neither should the community.  When vandals are caught they should be prosecuted and punished to the full extent of the law.  It's just mindless destruction and in this case it's destruction of someone else's creative expression.  No excuses, it's serious antisocial behavior.

Marty Richman

Thank you for your interest in the article. Though the concept has been utilized by societies for millennia, I recently heard the term "restorative justice" in local conversation and noted that law enforcement and the courts appear to be making a progressive effort to include the process in crime and punishment proceedings.

Here's the Wikipedia definition of Restorative Justice:

There are pros and cons to the appropriate judicial utility of Restorative Justice.

Critics of the process argue that Restorative Justice is not appropriate for some crimes, especially crimes that include sexual violence and/or deviant behavior perpetrated against the victims. 

But in this case, local artists seem to recognize that a youthful offender with some artistic talent may benefit from positive interaction with other artists by taking responsibility for his crime and helping to repair the damage he caused by defacing the collective creative expression of the mural. Perhaps the gesture made by Resendiz recognizes the antisocial behavior and seeks to rehabilitate it through pro-social collaboration and corrective community service work. Nobody wants vandals creeping around at night defacing public or private property but I leave it to the criminal justice experts to mitigate such crimes through the judicial process. 


Mike, yes, I believe that would be appropriate in this case.  Unfortunately, you often need the threat of using the regular justice system to force the offenders to take part in that process.  The key is to get the desired results, respect for the property of others and stopping the serious antisocial behavior.

Of course this is not a major crime, but it is a red flag showing that - typically - a young person has a serious blind spot that is only satisfied by destructive self-serving actions.  If those actions are not addresses they often end up with more serious actions and consequences.

Marty Richman

Add new comment

Add Facebook comment

Comment using your Facebook account. Facebook comments will be published on this page, and on Facebook. It will not be posted to the "Recent Comments" list on the BenitoLink front page.