Jim Patrick of the High Speed Rail Authority said funding sources for the bullet train route from the Central Valley through Pacheco Pass to Gilroy and San Francisco have yet to be determined, and offiicials are looking to cut project costs. Photo by John Chadwell.

Lea este artículo en español aquí.

Now exploring a range of potential revisions to the proposed bullet train route from Gilroy to the Central Valley through Pacheco Pass, the California High-Speed Rail Authority held a public environmental scoping meeting for the local project segment Nov. 4 at Casa de Fruta. 

When first designed, the section of the proposed rail line was planned to cross the Diablo Range south of Gilroy via the Pacheco Pass northeast down into Los Banos and over to Merced. 

But that original design has since changed to include as many as seven different routes or configurations from Gilroy through San Benito County and over Pacheco Pass. 

The one issue that no one from the authority addressed is there now appears to be no discernible benefit to the county because the one repair yard that was supposed to be built here is no longer in the plan. 

“I’d like to see the train stop in San Benito County, but I don’t think that’s going to happen,” San Benito County Supervisor Dom Zanger said, adding that he could not comment on his family’s concerns—they own Casa de Fruta and nearby farmlands—with the different routes.

“I think this project is still very preliminary but obviously we don’t like eminent domain and taking farmland,” He said. “It’s an ambitious project the state has taken on and it’s going to have issues, like taking someone’s farmland, and I don’t want that. We’re going to minimize that as much as possible.”

Grant Brians, who operates Heirloom Organic Gardens and has farmed in the Lovers Lane and Shore Road areas for many years, said he is concerned about the newly proposed routes because of flood issues.

“Every property that I farm on has at least one water course, so I’m very familiar with what happens when large amounts of rain falls,” he said. “I’m concerned that the rail project not exacerbate the issues, cut off access for farming operations, or take away too much farmland.”

Brians said if the route goes through the Soap Lake area there are major geological issues. 

“It’s my belief, based on the impact to the county, but also the geology and hydrology, that we need to make sure any tweaks that are made to the route prove that they’re cost-effective but don’t cause other problems,” he said.

In the original design south of Gilroy, the line would dip down into the northern end of the county, passing Soap Lake, Lovers Lane and through more than 20 farms. There was to be a repair yard but no depot in the area. 

Now, according to Agency State Regional Communications and Outreach Director Jim Patrick, there will be no yard, and the exact route through the county and costs are unknown because no environmental studies have been conducted yet.

“We can’t secure land until we complete an environmental process,” Patrick said, “When we have a draft environmental impact study in 2027, we’re going to have exact routes.”

Supervisor Dom Zanger expressed concern about how much land will be taken through eminent domain for the high speed rail project’s local segment. Photo by John Chadwell.

County resident Roxy Montana said she was curious about what the ridership would look like on the 119-mile section, its effects on San Benito County, and wondered “what was the point” of high-speed rail.

“Airports aren’t all that hard for us,” she said. “There are a lot of them between Northern and Southern California. If the cost for a train ticket is 80% of a plane ride there’s got to be a real benefit.”

Montana said she also wondered about security and who would be traveling on trains when the potential availability of autonomous air taxis are being developed in Hollister. 

“There’s a lot to consider,” she said. “It’s a lot of money. I’ll just wait and see because we’ve been waiting a long time.” 

The intended purpose of the meeting was to present project information, discuss alternative alignments and receive public comments for a supplemental environmental review. 

Patrick told BenitoLink that the current high speed rail project price is expected to be about $128 billion for the entire route from San Francisco to Anaheim, and the projected completion date is 2039. The original cost for the project was supposed to be $33 billion and the completion date was 2020.

He said the ultimate goal is for some of the trains to travel the entire route, nonstop at up to 200 miles per hour, in two hours and 40 minutes. Some trains will stop at nearly 40 stations along the route, while others will not. 

“We’re not stopping in Gilroy with that [bullet] train,” he said. “We’re not stopping in Merced. We can’t stop at all of our stations and get you to downtown L.A. in two hours and 40 minutes.”

According to the Authority’s 2008 business plan, after California voters approved Proposition 1A, the authority estimated the initial price tag would be about $33.6 billion. It was supposed to be paid for through a mix of approximately $9 billion in state bond funds, $12 billion to $16 billion in federal funding, $2 billion to $3 billion in local contributions, and roughly $6.7 billion to $7.5 billion from private investors and public-private partnerships. 

In 2019, the federal government canceled $929 million and in 2023 another $3.1 billion federal funding for the project, which had already been subject to delays and ballooning costs, but $929 million was restored by the Biden administration in 2021, and another $3.1 billion was added in December 2023.

Today, according to Patrick, the 119-mile segment is primarily being paid for through California’s cap-and-trade program, which is the state’s climate policy tied to what it considers major polluters such as oil refineries and large industrial facilities.

He said the cost of ridership from Merced to Bakersfield will be around $50 one-way but added he doesn’t expect commuters to be taking advantage of the service. Instead, he said he believes it will most likely be tourists and high speed rail enthusiasts.

“We’re not asking taxpayers to increase their tax bill to pay for the entire $128 billion,” he said. “We have about $35 billion in funding to complete the Central Valley, Merced to Bakersfield.”

Farmer Grant Brians said he is concerned about the rail going through the properties that he farms because of water and earthquake issues. Photo by John Chadwell.

He said the authority “feels” it has all the funding in place for the Central Valley portion but added “the trick is to get over to Gilroy because that’s when the line might begin making money.” 

“If we can get to Gilroy, we’re making money on fare sales from the Bay Area, taking people down to Bakersfield and getting them down to Los Angeles, probably via a bus to start with,” he said.

Patrick said the agency’s board purchased two new train sets from Siemens Mobility, the transportation subsidiary of Bavaria-based Siemens AG last week, and that the 119 miles stretch from Merced to Bakersfield will be operating in the red until the two ends-of-the line—Gilroy to San Francisco and Bakersfield to Los Angeles—are operational. 

According to an Oct. 29 article in the International Rail Journal, three train sets were purchased for $281.7 million, along with a 10-year, $284.1 million maintenance and full-service contract. There was also a proposed $63.7 million contingency account for possible import duties and tariffs.

Patrick confirmed that the first tracks will be laid in December starting in Merced, and that the authority already owns the right-of-way for the entire 119-mile segment, much of it secured through eminent domain. 

Obtaining land through  eminent domain is known as “condemnation actions” in which a government sues landowners by asking a court for permission to acquire the property. 

This would be of particular concern to landowners along Pacheco Pass, including the Zanger family, which owns Casa de Fruta and surrounding farmlands, and Montana, who lives on a hill nearby, because the new routes being contemplated could mean acquiring farmland, ranches, homes, easements, or portions of larger parcels.

During the meeting, several members of the Zanger family were huddled around a computer studying a Google Earth map which showed where each of the seven proposed routes might go. Several appeared to cross Zanger properties.

“The bottom line is we’re building the main line and it’s on local agencies and local communities to get people to what we call the last mile,” Patrick said. “It’s up to the locals to get them to that last mile.”

LaDonna DiCamillo, regional director of the authority, said with speeds of more than 200 miles per hour the 119-mile span will be considered a ”test track.” She said she knew that people have heard no track has been laid but said that is because the “guideway” (physical structures) must be completed first, so when the tracks are laid down “in ribbons” it can all be done at the same time. 

“Some of the optimizations we’re looking at is how to get to the population basis and how to get into Southern and Northern California faster,” DiCamillo said. “We’ve gone back and looked at our design requirements that give us opportunities to revisit alignments that we excluded in the past. If we have two tracks maybe we can get by with one track; we’ve changed our design requirements for grades. We don’t want to be a rollercoaster; we want to reduce the amount of tunneling that was required in this area.”

Stefon Galvez Abadia, environmental director for the authority, said the original route over the Pacheco Pass was approved in 2022. He said the agency is now attempting to optimize about 40 miles between Gilroy and Los Banos. The primary change, he said, is to “negotiate slopes at a higher rate” which would affect the number of tunnels and viaducts needed. 

“We’re looking at two additional alternatives south of San Luis Reservoir,” he said, adding that one of the routes would include a 14-mile-long tunnel. “We’re still refining these alternatives.”

Roxy Montana wondered about high speed rail ridership when air travel is easier to navigate. Photo by John Chadwell.

Related stories

We need your help. Support local, nonprofit news! BenitoLink is a nonprofit news website covering San Benito County. Our team is committed to this community and to providing essential, accurate information to our fellow residents. Producing local news is expensive, and community support keeps the news flowing. Please consider supporting BenitoLink, San Benito County’s public service nonprofit news.

John Chadwell works as a feature, news and investigative reporter for BenitoLink on a freelance basis. Chadwell first entered the U.S. Navy right out of high school in 1964, serving as a radioman aboard...