The 2026 Rib Cook Off in San Juan Bautista. Photo by Adam Bell.
The 2026 Rib Cook Off in San Juan Bautista. Photo by Adam Bell.

Lea este artículo en español aquí.

Promoter Jason Williams has withdrawn his permit requests for the 2027 San Juan Bautista Rib Cook-Off and the Arts and Crafts Festival over recently increased city fees. If no compromise is reached, the city would lose two key events from its calendar.

Williams, of Williams LTD, told BenitoLink that the city’s current charges, based on the recently updated fee schedule, make participating prohibitively expensive for vendors. 

“I am hopeful the city is negotiable on their fees,” he said, “but I’m not really optimistic because we’re so far apart. They’ve gone five times up on the vendor fees from what they were in the past. I can’t charge a vendor that much money and expect them to show up, you know?”

Williams said he had been in communications with San Juan Bautista City Council members and was waiting for a promised response from City Manager Ashley Collick, leaving everything in flux. 

“It’s not our goal to leave San Juan,” he said. “It’s just math. You know, the numbers just don’t make sense with what they’re asking for. So it’s not like I’m trying to throw a tantrum and leave. It just has to work for everybody.”

In a statement to BenitoLink, Collick said, “We recognize the value these longstanding events bring to San Juan Bautista, including their contributions to our downtown businesses and community character. We are disappointed that the promoter does not intend to proceed and understand the concerns being expressed.”

The City Council passed the fee schedule on June 16.  The increases were intended to address shortfalls between the “full burden” cost of staff time to process permits and the city’s current charges.

In her statement, Collick said, “The updated fees were part of a broader effort to establish a fair, consistent, and financially responsible approach to cost recovery across city operations, rather than changes (being) directed at any particular event or promoter.”

The difference between some new and old event fees is evident when comparing what the city charged for the June 27 Los Padrinos Annual Car Show with the current schedule, as detailed at the May 12 City Council meeting.

Among other fees, the Los Padrinos organizers were charged $800 to close Second, Third and Fourth streets and the side streets between Franklin and Muckelemi streets. Vendors, according to the permit application, were charged $15 a day.

The new fee schedule places the same street closures at $2,372, with the food vendor permits rising to $168. Other craft and merchandise vendors would be charged $126. 

Planning Commissioner Dan DeVries, who has been in contact with Williams, described the prospective cancellation as financially damaging for San Juan, resulting in lost tourist dollars and exposure.

“I think that this is a tragedy of significant proportion,” DeVries said. “And I’m at a loss as to why the city and the promoter can’t sit down and negotiate a deal that’s fair to both sides, so that everybody wins.”

The cook-off alone draws as many as 16,000 visitors over three days, and with the cancellation, the loss of revenue to markets, shops, restaurants and hotels will likely be substantial. 

Heliena Walton, owner of San Juan’s Notably Noble, said she was sad to see that the events might not move forward this year.

“I know for my store, we always see a financial impact during the event,” she said. “I definitely hope they resolve this because we’re already suffering. It’s a challenging financial terrain right now, and we need whatever we can to bring more eyes to our city, to get people to come out.”

City Councilmember Jose Aranda said the city is “between a rock and a hard place” when it comes to both encouraging events and charging enough so the city doesn’t lose money on them.

“I’m pro-business and pro-having events for our town,” he said. “But our fee schedule hadn’t been updated in years. We’ve been giving away services for free, and we need to be fiscally responsible.”

Aranda said that raising funds to resolve the city’s outstanding obligations, including improvements to the fire station and the ongoing water project, precluded losing money on discounted permits and fees. 

“If we give out breaks to one organizer,” he said, “we’re going to have to do it for everyone else. And if we start doing that, we’ll run into a deficit and be in a really bad financial position. But I would love us to hash this out with Jason and come to a middle ground.”

Collick said she had requested her staff to provide additional financial information from events held in previous years to better understand the city’s costs and the revenues associated with these events, as well as their broader economic contributions. 

Though the agenda has not been released yet, the cancellation of the festivals will likely be discussed at the next regular City Council meeting on Dec. 15 at 6 p.m.

Related stories

San Juan Bautista Fee Schedule

We need your help. Support local, nonprofit news! BenitoLink is a nonprofit news website covering San Benito County. Our team is committed to this community and to providing essential, accurate information to our fellow residents. Producing local news is expensive, and community support keeps the news flowing. Please consider supporting BenitoLink, San Benito County’s public service nonprofit news.