Government / Politics

Supervisors Send Fracking Initiative to Voters in November

San Benito County Board places San Benito Rising Anti-Fracking Initiative on ballot in November

San Benito County Supervisors voted 4-1, with First District Supervisor Margie Barrios in the minority, to place the San Benito Rising Initiative to Ban Fracking in San Benito County on the November ballot. Supervisor Barrios was in favor of a fiscal study to determine the cost of the initiative to the County, prior to proceeding. 

The Board had three options: to adopt the ordinance, to place it on the ballot, or to request a fiscal report. 

Third District Supervisor Robert Rivas and Second District Supervisor Anthony Bothelho spoke in strong support of the proposed ordinance.


The County Counsel has prepared the following ballot title and summary of the chief purpose and points of the proposed measure:


Ballot Title and Summary

Initiative to Ban Well Stimulation Treatments and Enhanced Recovery (such as Fracking and Steam Injection) throughout all Unincorporated Areas of San Benito County and to Ban All Petroleum Operations in Residential General Plan Designations in Unincorporated San Benito County and Make Related Zoning Changes

The proposed initiative would adopt new General Plan policies to prohibit:

(a)  the use of any land within the County’s unincorporated area for “High- Intensity Petroleum Operations”, as defined by the initiative to include well stimulation treatments (such as hydraulic fracturing, also known as fracking, and acid well stimulation treatments) and enhanced recovery wells (such as cyclic steam injection), and

(b)  the use of land with a residential General Plan land use designation —i.e., lands designated Rural, Rural Transitional, Rural Residential, Rural/Urban, and Sphere of Influence Rural/Urban—within the County’s unincorporated area for any Petroleum Operations.

“Petroleum Operations” includes all activities in connection with the exploration, drilling for, and the production of petroleum, gas and other hydrocarbons.

The initiative would establish a one-year amortization period for any existing High-Intensity Petroleum Operation(s) land use that has obtained a vested right under state law, as determined by the Planning Commission. The initiative provides a process by which well owners and operators may seek a determination from the Planning Commission to allow vested “High-Intensity Petroleum Operations” land uses to continue by an extension of the amortization period up to a maximum of three years. The initiative would not apply to any “Low-Intensity Petroleum Operation”, as defined, that has obtained a vested right under state law by the time the measure becomes effective.

The measure would also add new sections to the Zoning Title (Title 25) and the Oil and Gas Well Chapter (Chapter 19.21) of the San Benito County Code to implement the new General Plan policies. Section 25.29.161 would prohibit any development or construction or use of facilities or equipment for “High Intensity Petroleum Operations.” Section 25.29.162 would prohibit the development, construction, or use of any facilities or equipment for Petroleum Operations in Rural and Residential Zoning Districts, e.g.

Rural (R), Rural Transitional (RT), Rural Residential (RR), Single-Family Residential (R1) and Residential Multiple (RM), except to the extent that “Low-Intensity Petroleum Operations” had already obtained a vested right.

General Plan policies and County Code provisions adopted through the initiative could not be amended or repealed except by a vote of County voters. The San Benito County Board of Supervisors may grant exceptions to application of the Initiative if the Board finds that the application would constitute a unconstitutional taking of property and the exception would be such to allow land uses only to the minimum extent necessary to avoid a unconstitutional taking.

The Initiative provides that the Board of Supervisors shall take all steps reasonably necessary to enforce the Initiative and defend it against any challenge.

If another measure appears on the same ballot and conflicts with any portion of the Initiative, then the measure receiving the most votes shall prevail. 

BenitoLink Staff