Lea este artículo en español aquí.
Citing an absence of evidence or even any specific allegations of wrongdoing, the California Secretary of State’s office told BenitoLink it won’t look into anonymous concerns regarding the election for District 5 county supervisor.
“If any evidence is submitted to our office, we will review it and determine what action, if any, is necessary,” the Secretary of State press team said in an email to BenitoLink when asked if the department in charge of state elections oversight would review the concerns forwarded by San Benito County Sheriff Eric Taylor.
The email also noted that state elections code provides for candidates to pursue a recount.
Last week, Taylor sent a memo to the Secretary of State, the California Dep[artment of Justice, the District Attorney, and County Counsel reporting that a person who requested to remain anonymous was concerned that duplicated ballots “might not accurately reflect voter’s intent.”
According to Taylor’s memo, the person also raised concerns about an alleged emergency closed-door meeting involving San Benito County Registrar of Voters Francisco Diaz and other election officials to prepare for a “fallout” if former Supervisor Ignacio Velazquez lost the lead in his bid to reclaim the seat he lost to recall in June.
The memo went on to say the discussion among election officials was about “damage control” if Velazquez requested a manual count of the ballots or an audit of the duplicate ballots.
Candidate Rodney Bianchi currently leads Velazquez by 21 votes with only 411 ballots deemed challenged or damaged to be processed. Bianchi trailed Velazquez by as many as 67 votes in earlier returns.
Diaz told BenitoLink his office welcomes state oversight, though he has not received any formal or informal communication from the Secretary of State.
In addressing the concern about closed-door meetings raised by the Taylor’s memo, Diaz said leadership members routinely meet to plan for “standard administrative and operational contingencies, including staffing, budgeting, and potential recount procedures.”
“Characterizing these routine preparations as improper reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of standard election administration and management,” he said.
He went on to say that the process to duplicate ballots is mandated by the state and is conducted in public view and open to authorized observers.
“Any audit comparing original ballots to duplicated copies will confirm that voter intent was accurately preserved,” he said.
Taylor told BenitoLink that he is happy and relieved the Secretary of State didn’t see “any cause for alarm or concern.”
“I hope that exonerates the elections office and makes everybody that was worried about it feel better,” he said.
Taylor’s memo is dated Nov. 15, two days after Bianchi overtook Velazquez and established a 13-votes lead, which has since expanded.
With regard to his request to the state for guidance on preserving relevant materials for any potential investigation regarding election irregularities, Taylor said he didn’t get any such guidance from the Secretary of the State. He said he only got confirmation that the office had received his memo and officials would look into it.
Taylor also said he never received a response from the state Department of Justice.
He went on to say that he sent the memo to District Attorney Joel Buckingham because his office is the investigatory agency in election cases.
Buckingham acknowledged he received the memo but said his office did not conduct any investigation because he was waiting for a response from the state. He said he had not received any communication from the state as of Nov. 20.
“Our office hasn’t directly received any anonymous complaints regarding the election,” Buckingham said. “We have the referral. The referral is not necessarily something, given the posture of the state, that is something we will be acting upon at this particular moment.”
He went on to say that can change if the state directs his office to look into the matter.
Buckingham said when election complaints are received by his office, an attempt is made to independently substantiate the claims by following up with the reporting party or by other evidence that can corroborate the claims.
Neither San Benito County Counsel Gregory Priamos nor county supervisors immediately responded to BenitoLink’s requests for comment, nor did Bianchi.
We need your help. Support local, nonprofit news! BenitoLink is a nonprofit news website covering San Benito County. Our team is committed to this community and to providing essential, accurate information to our fellow residents. Producing local news is expensive, and community support keeps the news flowing. Please consider supporting BenitoLink, San Benito County’s public service nonprofit news.
