Two election volunteers duplicate a ballot on Nov. 4, 2026. Photo by Noe Magaña.
Two San Benito County elections volunteers duplicate a ballot during the vote counting process on Nov. 4. Photo by Noe Magaña.

Lea este artículo en español aquí.

San Benito County Sheriff Eric Taylor has sent a memo to county and California state legal authorities seeking assistance with an anonymous complaint involving the Nov. 3 District 5 supervisorial race.

Taylor sent the memo to County Counsel Gregory Priamos, San Benito County District Attorney Joel Buckingham, the California secretary of state’s investigative division and the office of the California attorney general. 

BenitoLink became aware of the memo when the San Benito County Board of Supervisors on Nov. 17 discussed an urgency item regarding the memo, outlining “unverified concerns” about duplicate ballots and voter intent in this month’s election, specifically involving the District 5 race.

In the memo, Taylor refers to a conversation “reportedly overheard by a person in the elections office shortly before 11 a.m.” on Nov. 13 by a person he said wishes to remain anonymous. 

“According to the account relayed to me, election leadership appeared unsettled by the possibility that Rodney Bianchi would overtake Ignacio Velasquez in the District 5 Supervisor race,” Taylor wrote. “The account described Velasquez as having maintained the lead since Election Day. These descriptions have not been independently verified for purposes of this referral.”

It was on Nov. 13 when the county elections results update showed challenger Rodney Bianchi, who was trailing in earlier vote tallies, had overtaken former Supervisor Ignacio Velazquez, who is seeking to reclaim the county board seat from which he was recalled in June. According to the latest tally, Bianchi holds a 25-vote lead. 

Taylor also wrote, “The account also included a rumor that Registrar of Voters Francisco Diaz and others held a closed-door emergency meeting about how to handle the fallout if Velasquez fell behind in the latest count. I have not confirmed that such a meeting occurred, who attended, or what was discussed. It is also unclear which portions of this account the reporting person personally overheard and which were relayed by others.”

The reported discussion, according to Taylor’s memo, “included references to ‘damage control’ if Velasquez requested a manual count or an audit of ‘duplicate ballots.’ The concern conveyed was that the duplicate ballots might not accurately reflect voters’ intent.”

Taylor explained in the memo that “ballot duplication is a lawful process used to reproduce ballots that cannot otherwise be processed, while preserving the voter’s choices.”

In the memo, Taylor noted that his wife is employed as a senior deputy clerk-recorder under Diaz and handled ballot pickups during this election.  

“I disclose these facts because her employment and election duties may create a potential conflict of interest or an appearance of a conflict concerning my involvement in this matter,” he wrote. 

In the memo, Taylor requested for Priamos, in coordination with Buckingham and appropriate state authorities, to “assess whether recusal or other safeguards are warranted and identify an independent agency to lead any review. Pending that guidance, I will refrain from personally directing investigative activity in this matter.”

Taylor continued: “This referral makes no finding that fraud occurred and attributes no wrongdoing to Diaz, either candidate, or any other person. The information may be incomplete, misunderstood, or inaccurate. Nevertheless, the reported concern about voter intent warrants referral to the appropriate authorities for evaluation.”  

After the meeting, Taylor posted a statement on Facebook saying he was frustrated that the memorandum had been shared with the media prior to its statements being substantiated. BenitoLink has been unable to identify any other media outlets that received the memo.

Taylor did not immediately respond to messages from BenitoLink. 

During the supervisors’ discussion, Supervisor Kollin Kosmicki said the comments he was going to make during the meeting were not meant as an “accusation of wrongdoing,” but the matter should be taken seriously. Kosmicki did note that Diaz was present at the board meeting when the board added the urgency item but left afterward and did not return to the chambers.

“I feel strongly that the public deserves to know what is happening,” Kosmicki said.

Kosmicki noted that the memo from Taylor indicates election workers knew of a shift in advance of the Nov. 13 report, adding that a shift like the one in District 5 is an “anomaly.” 

Supervisor Mindy Sotelo said the memo’s contents were concerning and elections must have integrity, adding that the supervisors and county should remain neutral regarding the concerns expressed in the memo.

Sotelo noted that the results in the Hollister Mayor and Hollister City Council races also changed. “Maybe this is just one of those years,” she said.

Supervisor Angela Curro, a former elections official, said it is hard when election results “ping pong,” which she said is a formal term used in an elections office when numbers are shifting.

Ballot duplication, she said, is part of the election process and is usually done by a minimum of two staffers and sometimes as many as four.

Until election results are released, “we never say we know a winner,” Curro said. She also noted that elections are not easy and “we [elections officials] are only human.”

She said she did not doubt the secretary of state’s office would get involved if needed, but said she hoped the county would not prejudge or get involved in specific cases.

Curro said members of the public are always invited to oversee the election ballot counting process, and those comments were echoed by board chairman Dom Zanger, who encouraged public involvement in elections.

Zanger said the issues presented by Taylor were “obviously important” and added that he hopes the appropriate entities perform their due diligence and “hold a rigorous standard to this.”

No formal action was taken on the item, but county representatives have told BenitoLink there will be no involvement from the county moving forward.

“There is no role for the county at this point,” Priamos said in a statement. “It is entirely up to the appropriate agencies to review the allegations and take whatever action they deem necessary. It is also up to the candidate to avail themselves of the remedies provided for under the law.” 

After the meeting, Buckingham told BenitoLink, “The District Attorney’s Office was included as a courtesy copy on an email sent to state agencies asking for guidance. At the current time, the District Attorney’s Office does not have any further information or comment, as it would be out of turn given said referral to state authorities.”

“To protect their integrity, we’re unable to comment on, even to confirm or deny, potential or ongoing investigations,” a representative from the Department of Justice wrote in an email.

After the meeting, Velazquez said he was made aware of the concerns about duplicate ballots and voter intent, as well as the fact that Taylor had requested involvement from the secretary of state and Department of Justice.

“It was very odd” to see vote counts change drastically on Nov. 13, he said, noting that other people have been concerned about the change and have called it unlikely.

“I thought the sheriff did a great job to not get in the middle, but recognize there was a concern,” Velazquez said.

He said he was also concerned by allegations that voting boxes had not been locked after 8 p.m. on Election Day and recalled witnessing a truck dropping off more ballots after voting ended. 

He said he personally visited the county elections office and was told any ballots dropped off after 8 p.m. would not be counted, “but now we are seeing a turnaround,” though he didn’t explain what he meant by a “turnaround.” 

He argued the matter should be investigated by a third party. “A lot of things can be done to ensure nothing improper happened,” Velazquez added.

Velazquez called it “scary” that something could have happened in the election.

Bianchi said he was not aware of the concerns, but was glad Taylor reported the matter, adding, “I definitely want transparency.”

John Williams, the third candidate for the supervisor seat, did not immediately respond to BenitoLink’s request for comment.

“Elections belong to the people, and our sole duty is to count every lawful ballot with complete transparency and integrity,” Diaz told BenitoLink after the meeting.

“Our doors remain open to observers and state oversight, and no mischaracterization of routine staffing, budget or contingency planning changes our strict adherence to California election law,” he said. 

Noe Magaña contributed to this article.

The BenitoLink Internship Program is a paid, skill-building program that prepares local youth for a professional career. This program is supported by Monterey Peninsula Foundation AT&T Golf Tour and Taylor Farms.